Zain Shared Internet

Jan 17, 2008

Zain Shared Internet

(Click to enlarge pic)

38 Comments, Comment or Ping

wakim

Why the cup cake!? it would have been nicer without it and keep the plate empty and open for anything that goes in it. The base idea is to share. The cup cake gave an extra meaning (whether positive or negative) that the reader doesn’t need.

Jan 17th, 2008
Mai

I saw this in the morning, I wished to see it here :)

I loved the color, the background, but in the begning I thought there was a mistake, as the e-go is for one laptop! Its not a router! Only now I read here in the description, so I beleive its misleading! If I did not see it here I wont know! Its simple, and I see it good, although I agree with WAKIM about the cupcake. And 12 persons on 1 cupcake? :D

Jan 17th, 2008
Zeid Nasser

Not bad….

Who’s the ad agency?

Jan 17th, 2008
Mark

As a meaning an empty plate with a lot of spoons or a cupcake with a lot of spoons they both mean the same thing… sharing. Visually on the other hand the cupcake is more attractive then an empty plate.

Jan 17th, 2008
Real Creative

12 spoons on a tiny cup cake ? isnt that negative by its self ? sharing a small piece ?! with 11 other people ?? there might be better ways to look into this task. i dont think it works, it seems as first layer thinking and should be pushed to a second round to get better results. it looks pretty, beautifully executed and all that..

BUT..

conceptually, makes no sense, does not make me want to upgrade to/ or buy this product. i will think directly about how big is my piece out of this piece. (which is bandwidth when we translate it to internet lingo)

Since, zain is all about a beautiful world, and uptill now their visuals include a human element, they should of looked into the direction of sharing amongst humans and literally projected that onto the Advert itself.

but be happy, good job with all the execution. the first ad i have ever seen with 6 colors and yet looks simple.

Jan 17th, 2008
Mai

I agree with mark, walla I was thinking that it wont look good if its empty plate! lets share an orange better than a cupcake :P the cupcake looks small to share

Jan 18th, 2008
Moey

Nice work from JWT Kuwait :)

Jan 19th, 2008
Kre8tive

What you’d get is only a “small” portion since there’s a “lot sharing” from a “small offering”. Not very promising. They should make the cup cake very big. 3/10.

Jan 19th, 2008
Moey

it is a usb device that they’re sharing, cupcake works better

Jan 19th, 2008
Kre8tive

Nice try Moey, ain’t working though.

Jan 19th, 2008
Sami

Damn it…this concept has been over used…i’ve seen more than 10 ads with the same idea for different products…

Jan 20th, 2008
Mark

Can everyone here tell me what school they went to please??? You are not qualified to review the ad! Please where is everyones cv post it here!! Please ads2blog I don’t like this here. Please remove this ad and all comments!!!!!!!!!!

Note: This was me doing a Patrick Semaan impression
http://www.ads2blog.com/2007/08/29/c-cube-results-oriented/

Jan 20th, 2008
Kre8tive

You can’t stop the guys from throwing Insane comments on your ad, Mark… If people wanted to trash it, they will… like you said in the link, “chill dude” and guys, please be polite:-P

Jan 20th, 2008
mark

Kre8tive you know I was kidding with my comment right?

(or maybe you got the fact that i was joking around and your reply was you joking around back at me but I didn’t get it)

Jan 20th, 2008
Kre8tive

Exactly! Now you blew it, we could’ve stretched this into like a hundred comments more :-(

Jan 20th, 2008
mark

fuckkkkkkkkkk that would have been cool. you should have emailed me and told me!

Jan 20th, 2008
Kre8tive

Ma’alesh. (Next time)

Jan 20th, 2008
Real Creative

ok im sorry ill be polite but this ad is crap

Jan 20th, 2008
Moey

I still like it better than the “my princess” crap.

Jan 21st, 2008
Kre8tive

Real Creative… we do like to throw “Harsh” words when criticizing ads, like these… I do agree this ad fell off short or should I say, OVERKILL.. now, can U please explain further the meaning of “CRAP”? Mark… pay attention, please.

Jan 21st, 2008
Mark

I am here listening. Waiting for Real Creative to reply.

Real Creative is Louai just for everyones information.

Jan 21st, 2008
Moey

hehe, really Mark? same IP? LOL…

Jan 21st, 2008
Real Creative

LOL, u just wish i was Louai man, Mark maybe my first comment will be ur advertising first advertising lesson ;) yeah and thats for little ol’ Kreative too :p niXXXaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaz :p

Jan 21st, 2008
Kre8tive

Ey Yo Real Creative, I don’t give a rat’s ass about whoever you are, Do you know who I am? See? So STFU and answer my friggin’ question why you call this ad “CR*P”… don’t gimme excuses :-P

Jan 22nd, 2008
Mark

“maybe my first comment will be ur advertising first advertising lesson”

and in return maybe I could help you out with some English lessons?

But seriously though with a nickname like “Real Creative” I would really be interested in hearing what you have to say about the ad without you needing to sound all hip and black.

Jan 22nd, 2008
Real Creative

KRE8TIVE u arse !
lol man this ad is crap cause it lacks the concept. the metaphore isnt working at all, biatch ! read the first comment i posted and stop nagging.

Jan 23rd, 2008
Kre8tive

Real Creative, stop holding ur Fart, that’s when u get sh*tty ideas, and bad mouth:-P lol… Real Creative is so lame as a name.

Jan 23rd, 2008
Kre8tive

For some reasons, my comments are being filtered.. A2B?

Jan 23rd, 2008
Kre8tive

Anyways, whatever. RC, hit me with your rationale about this ad. Give us your thoughts (if you are going to create something like this). Everyone please listen :-)

Jan 23rd, 2008
Mark

lol biatch!

Jan 24th, 2008
Moey

what’s going on here!

Jan 26th, 2008
Moonstar

Honestly this is a very normal ad. Not Wow, should have been more creative.

Creative Direction : 2/10
Art Direction : 5/10

Jan 26th, 2008
Kre8tive

Um Excuse me Moonstar, which ad school you come from and what’s your credentials to criticize this ad? (Hello, Patrick) lol

Jan 27th, 2008
Moey

Moonstar? is that a typo

Jan 27th, 2008
Mark

Moonstar is made up of two words, moon and star so this means he is disqualified from reviewing ads here

Jan 27th, 2008
Kre8tive

….Maybe Moonstar is Louai?

Jan 28th, 2008
Moonstar

I gave my honest feedback on this ad KRE8TIVE.

The concept is only about the tasty cup and spoons sharing them. It is not the ad that will make you sell but it is the brand. This type of “sharing” idea has been used regionally and internationally before many times.

And by the way this website is not just for some people who claim to be qualified professors of some creative schools but it is also for the public comments.

I am Moonstar (from Silverhawks) not Louai!

Feb 1st, 2008
Kre8tive

Thank you for being honest, Stardust or Silvermoon or whatever.

Feb 2nd, 2008

Reply to “Zain Shared Internet”

3 simple blog comment rules: stay on-topic, no personal attacks/name calling and no direct advertisement for products or websites.(ads2blog.com welcomes debate and does not censor. It does; however, remove or modify comments that are ill-tempered or contain materials deemed inappropriate)

[All comments posted on this site express only the views of the commentators and not necessarily those of ads2blog.com team]

Before you go

Check out these cool links.

Zain Shared Internet

38 Comments, Comment or Ping

Reply to “Zain Shared Internet”

Categories

Links

Subscribe

Meta

Before you go

Recent Comments